Blog Jay Leiderman Law

In American jurisprudence it suffices that the testimony of one witness who is believed is sufficient for a conviction.  The Bible disagrees.  The Bible says the following in Deuteronomy 19:15, as it relates to criminal inquests and prosecutions:

“A single witness shall not suffice against a person for any crime or for any wrong in connection with any offense that he has committed. Only on the evidence of two witnesses or of three witnesses shall a charge be established.”  The Bible; English Standard Version

Bible

California allows the testimony of one witness to convict in a criminal case. The bible calls for two witnesses.

In discussing the application this provision of the bible, Matthew Henry stated: 

“19:15-21 Sentence should never be passed upon the testimony of one witness alone. A false witness should suffer the same punishment which he sought to have inflicted upon the person he accused. Nor could any law be more just. Let all Christians not only be cautious in bearing witness in public, but be careful not to join in private slanders; and let all whose consciences accuse them of crime, without delay flee for refuge to the hope set before them in Jesus Christ.”

A single witness shall not suffice

California law disagrees.  The instruction given in a trial by the Judge to the jury after the close of evidence but prior to deliberations is in direct conflict with Deuteronomy.  

CALCRIM 301. Single Witness’s Testimony

The testimony of only one witness can prove any fact. Before you conclude that the testimony of one witness proves a fact, you should carefully review all the evidence.

Bible

God’s law conflicts with man’s law. Man’s law is used in our courts and people are often convicted by witnesses providing false testimony. n

It wasn’t the idea of the law of God that one snitch could send a defendant to death row.  But in the law of man we don’t worry about such things.  A lack of proof via corroboration is one of the central problems with our justice system.  False accusations abound.  Of the people exonerated through DNA evidence, the overwhelming majority were convicted either by false testimony or mistaken eyewitness testimony.  Maybe it isn’t such a bad idea to look at the bible’s definition of witnesses necessary to convict.  If one injustice is prevented it may well be worth it.

 

 

 

twitter Facebooktwittergoogle_pluslinkedinmail

Jay Leiderman Jay Leiderman Law
Fighting the Man for You

Criminal Defense Attorney Jay Leiderman

When searching for the right attorney, it is often the worst time in your life. Finding a good one, and the right one for you, is a daunting task. At Jay Leiderman Law, we have proven results over years of practice, and we are uniquely qualified to represent you in your time of need. Jay Leiderman Law believes that they are the right firm for you for many, many reasons.

The Law Offices of Jay Leiderman looks forward to assisting you in your time of need. We offer FREE consultations to all prospective clients.

Address & Contact Information

Jay Leiderman Law
770 County Square Drive Suite 101
Ventura, California 93003

Tel: (805) 654-0200
Fax: (805) 654-0280


Go Back
 

7 Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


*